× Didn't find what you were looking for? Ask a question
Top Posters
Since Sunday
6
o
5
4
m
4
b
4
x
4
a
4
l
4
t
4
S
4
m
3
s
3
New Topic  
Eranu Eranu
wrote...
13 years ago
Hi guys,

enjoying reading through these posts however i have a problem of my own i could do with a helping hand

I have a question on an article http://www.pnas.org/content/107/5/1815.full  that i need to comment on in relation to the following question.

The question  is that for  lizards collected from the White Sands habitat, why would the dominant or recessive nature of the light Mc1r allele in fence and whiptail lizard species, ie dominant in the fence lizard and recessive in the whiptail, result in the difference seen in light allele frequency between the two different species.

Many thanks
Read 2962 times
8 Replies

Related Topics

Replies
wrote...
Valued Member
Educator
13 years ago
This is a classical case of convergent evolution. Convergent evolution is when various species evolve similar solutions to similar evolutionary pressures, independently and often at different times. So while both lizards how the Mc1r gene, one species has managed to turn it off (likely via transcription factors), while the other likely required it to be transcribed into protein in order to survive.
Eranu Author
wrote...
13 years ago
Thanks for reply bro, i understand what u r saying but how does that relate particularly to the recessive or dminant allele in the respective species???

Cheers
wrote...
Valued Member
Educator
13 years ago
In the fence lizard, the blanched allele is dominant, its frequency never exceeds 50% in any habitat, and it is completely absent from the dark-soil area. It needs to be dominant in this allele or else it will be susceptible to predation and will not exist over time. Those that were not dominant for this allele had to migrate where it was safe. It needed to produce more melanin so that it could probably camouflage itself (This is my hypothesis, although I'm not 100% sure). In contrast, blanched allele is recessive in the whiptail lizard, it is nearly fixed in white-sand habitats, and it persists at low frequency in the dark-soil region. Therefore, this specifies didn't like have to produce as much melanin in its respected region of inhabitance. Those that were dark were preyed upon whereas those that were white could hide in the sand.

What do you have in mind other than predation?
Eranu Author
wrote...
13 years ago
Thats why im confused, if the light allele is dominant in the fence lizard in the white sands area why is it not present in higher frequencies? I would of thoght it would be 3:1 in favour of the light allele even taking into account slection pressure from predation, conversely the whiptail lizard is present in much higher numbers yet it is recessive in this species - it seems the opposite way round. I think thats what the questions is trying to reason why there isnt the expected 3:1 ratio
wrote...
Valued Member
Educator
13 years ago
In a perfect world, yes - you'd find 3 to 1 but there are always other factors that determine these ratios (i.e. epistasis). You seem very knowledgeable in the field, glad to have you as a member!
Eranu Author
wrote...
13 years ago
Lol i wish i was mate, i just cant figure this one out - even taking into account geneflow, and natural selection pressures it doesnt make sense to me LOL

wrote...
Valued Member
Educator
13 years ago
Hate to say it, but I'm not too sure either Undecided. The article, though well-written, doesn't mention anything about sexual selection. Do you think it could have an impact?
Eranu Author
wrote...
13 years ago
Maybe , that was one thought i had that even if the light allele is dominant, the ones with the wild type allele will be more attractive to mates but i dont think it can apply t this particular question as like u pointed out theres no reference in the article to it.

The question is basically asking what s the relationship between the allele being domainant or recessive and the frequency of the alleles in the white sands environment - im stumped to be honest

Thats night shift over - off to bed 8)
New Topic      
Explore
Post your homework questions and get free online help from our incredible volunteers
  861 People Browsing
 111 Signed Up Today
Related Images
  
 888
  
 6
  
 1525
Your Opinion
How often do you eat-out per week?
Votes: 79