× Didn't find what you were looking for? Ask a question
Top Posters
Since Sunday
g
3
3
2
J
2
p
2
m
2
h
2
s
2
r
2
d
2
l
2
a
2
New Topic  
Lazzini Lazzini
wrote...
Posts: 2
Rep: 0 0
7 years ago
Let me begin by stating that my question is prompted by curiosity allied to almost total lack of knowledge of biology and evolution.

I have seen fireflies flying around flashing their signals. As I understand it, these signals are produced by male fireflies and detected by females on the ground who respond by flashing back, the whole process leading to an eventual meeting and coupling. Now, as admitted, I am an ignoramus in these my matters, but my understanding is that evolution occurs by minute changes that bring minute advantages that eventually lead to predominance of these changes throughout a population.

Although I understand how this may work in, for instance, the development of the eye, the case of the firefly is more problematical for me. It requires the development of a flashing mechanism in both sexes. It also requires the development of a response mechanism in the female to the flash of the male. Until any of these three developments are complete, it seems to me, there is no advantage whatsoever in the intermediate stages. When the three developments must, of necessity, occur simultaneously to confer any advantage to the species as a whole, the probability of this happening seems to be infinitesimal - but it has happened.

Can someone please bring enlightenment to an ignoramus?
Read 483 times
2 Replies

Related Topics

Replies
Lazzini Author
wrote...
6 years ago
There must be someone, surely, among the membership of this forum who can provide some sort of answer to my query. I'm not a biologist, and I came to the forum because it seemed to be an obvious source of knowledge on what is, after all, a biological question. Any offers?
wrote...
Educator
6 years ago
Luciferase, the enzyme involved in created light from ATP, didn't appear into existence suddenly. It is actually related to a highly preserved enzyme used in the overall metabolic pathway, known as fatty acyl-CoA synthetase, which is responsible for fatty acid biosynthesis. So when scientists approached this question, your question, they started off decoding the protein, luciferase, by comparing its gene to other genes found in the species and related species to find any relatives to it.

As mentioned, fatty acyl-CoA synthetase is an enzyme that plays a key role in fat metabolism, creating an intermediary that allows cells to add more carbons onto growing chains of fatty acids. Not surprisingly, luciferase nearly does the same thing. It catalyzes a very similar reaction, but works with a specialized chemical that produces a lot of light. However, if you put fatty acyl-CoA synthetase in with the specialized chemical that makes fireflies glow, nothing happens. This raised the question of how the ability to produce light began to be selected for in the first place; if there's no light, there's nothing to select.

The author of this paper, which I suggest you read -- http://www.pnas.org/content/111/12/4443 -- reasoned that the process must have started with a mundane, non-glowing fatty acyl-CoA synthetase. If that was identical, then it probably meant that the glow came from a less specialized chemical. So they began testing relatives of the firefly chemical, using the fatty acyl-CoA synthetase from the fruit fly Drosophila. They quickly found a chemical that, when given to Drosophila cells, caused them to emit a dull, red glow. If they put the fly version of fatty acyl-CoA synthetase into human cells, giving them the same chemical would cause them to glow, as well.

The results suggest that a random accident - getting the right chemical in cells with a particular enzyme - provided enough glow for evolution to start selecting for it. And, with enough time, both the chemical and the enzyme became specialized, producing a brighter, more intense glow.
New Topic      
Explore
Post your homework questions and get free online help from our incredible volunteers
  1120 People Browsing
 120 Signed Up Today
Related Images
  
 428
  
 622
  
 3445