× Didn't find what you were looking for? Ask a question
Top Posters
Since Sunday
w
3
w
3
e
3
3
r
3
b
2
M
2
V
2
f
2
c
2
c
2
K
2
New Topic  
Sheeno Sheeno
wrote...
Posts: 3
Rep: 0 0
10 years ago
Hello everyone! I'm having a lot of trouble with this question. You're supposed to choose the one answer that is most correct..

A species of squirrel lives in pine forest. A large river runs through the squirrel's habitat forming two large areas of pine forest. The squirrels are unable to swim and consequently only mate with squirrels on the same side. The squirrels from each side of the river look identical to each other. When they are given the opportunity to mate they do so but they are unable to produce any offspring, Which of the following is true?

A. The squirrels have undergone allopatric speciation.
B. The squirrels have undergone sympatic speciation.
C. The squirrels from each side of the river are the same species.
D. There are premating barriers to reproduction between the squirrels from each side of the river.

I'm not sure if the answer is A or D! I think D is correct because there is a premating barrier to reproduction - the big river in the way. However, seeing as they are reproductively isolated, I think they might be considered different species and therefore allopatrically speciated. But the question says they look identical, so do they qualify as having undergone speciation or not? It doesn't help that it begins with "A species of squirrel" which implies there is no speciation. But if they haven't undergone speciation, then C is correct - but maybe it's not the one to choose if it's not the most correct?

Any help would be greatly appreciated!

Read 607 times
4 Replies

Related Topics

Replies
wrote...
10 years ago
I think D is the correct answer  =)
Sheeno Author
wrote...
10 years ago
Thanks a lot for your response! So an animal can't have undergone speciation if it still looks the same? They do like to try and trick us with these multiple choice questions...
wrote...
10 years ago
the answer is D the reason given is correct
Sheeno Author
wrote...
10 years ago
Thank you! What is confusing me and making me worried the answer is not D is that it says "premating barriers". Whilst the river that separates them is a premating barrier because it prevents them from meeting, shouldn't they be able to fertilise each other when they do meet as the barrier is removed? The question says that when they do meet no offspring is produced, however, so I was thinking that there is instead a postmating barrier - i.e. the issue lies in gametic incompatibility. This is what makes me think that it is possible they have undergone allopatric speciation, based on the definition of "species" as a group of interbreeding organisms.

Thank you for your help! I'm not trying to undermine you, but if you or anyone could explain where I've gone wrong it would be very much appreciated. Slight Smile This is revision for an exam so I just want to make sure I understand everything fully!
New Topic      
Explore
Post your homework questions and get free online help from our incredible volunteers
  399 People Browsing
Related Images
  
 177
  
 74
  
 130