× Didn't find what you were looking for? Ask a question
Top Posters
Since Sunday
t
7
m
6
k
6
F
5
j
5
t
5
j
5
G
5
f
5
a
5
d
5
c
5
New Topic  
efj4422 efj4422
wrote...
Posts: 147
Rep: 0 0
3 years ago
3.   Define “Extraordinary Care”.    What is the medical community’s compatible term?
 The answer to this is -->The term “Extraordinary Care” refers to providing patients with the access of high quality/expensive medication, operations, treatments that may cause series/harmful side effects that may not offer any hope or benefit for their current illness. Comparing this to ordinary care, patients are given the basic necessities in order to maintain their wellbeing such as food, water, or other care that comforts the patient. The Catholic Church’s response to this case is that no patient shouldn’t be denied with the care or medical treatment they need. While Pope Pius XII had spoke the differences and importance between extraordinary care and ordinary care, the medical community’s compatible term for this is proportionate and disproportionate care to define the same truths.
But my question is what is the meaning behind those terms, "proportionate and disproportionate care" and why do they define it this way rather than the Catholic Church does extraordinary care and ordinary care, if that makes sense.
Read 71 times
2 Replies

Related Topics

Replies
wrote...
Educator
3 years ago
The Church says that any treatment that offers a reasonable hope of benefit and is not too burdensome for the patient or others would be considered proportionate. What is a reasonable hope of benefit to the patient should be judged within the context of the whole person (i.e., considered beyond the mere physiological or medical). Generally, a treatment is not too burdensome when it offers benefits that outweigh the burdens to the patient and to others.

A disproportionate means is any treatment that either offers no reasonable hope of benefit (taking into account the well-being of the whole person) or is too burdensome for the patient or others, i.e., the burdens or risks are disproportionate to or outweigh the expected benefits of the treatment.

Is that making more sense?
 Attached file 
You must login or register to gain access to this attachment.
efj4422 Author
wrote...
3 years ago
Thanks again bio_man! Slight Smile
New Topic      
Explore
Post your homework questions and get free online help from our incredible volunteers
  985 People Browsing
Related Images
  
 407
  
 820
  
 267
Your Opinion
What's your favorite coffee beverage?
Votes: 299

Previous poll results: Where do you get your textbooks?