× Didn't find what you were looking for? Ask a question
Top Posters
Since Sunday
g
1
1
New Topic  
asmith713 asmith713
wrote...
Posts: 17
Rep: 0 0
12 years ago
im doing a project on it, why do certain crops contain so many extra antibiotics and pesticides in them?
Read 352 times
3 Replies

Related Topics

Replies
wrote...
12 years ago
Inorder to end up the need to use agro chemicals fr the crop cultivation. Ths is because the genes put into them help produce chemicals like pesticides themseves to kill away any pests or weeds to improve crop yeild...
wrote...
12 years ago
Who says they do?  Where did you hear this?  Crops, grains and vegetables have to antibiotics in them.  Period.  Meat products "could" have antibiotic residues in them if the withdrawal period is not followed, but the chances of that happening is highly unlikely because if found, that would result in the recall and destruction of millions of dollars worth of meat products.  Not good business.  

There's no pesticides in GMOs either.  Bt corn has the naturally occurring, soil borne bacillus thurengis bacteria DNA added to the corn genome.  The Bt bacteria itself isn't a pesticide, although it is deadly to some insects.  Just like peanuts; some people are extremely allergic to them and will die if ingested, others like me can eat a bucket full and never suffer any ill effects at all.  Or poison ivy, I get blisters if I barely touch it.  My sheep relish it and eat it with gusto, while never getting any negative reaction whatsoever.  No blisters on their lips, tongue or anything.  Bt is deadly to corn borers but won't faze a grasshopper, aphid, etc.
wrote...
12 years ago
Asking a question like that would make it appear that the person asking you to investigate it is somewhat biased and inflammatory in regard to crop genetics ? much in the way asking someone ?why do rednecks beat their wives so much? or ?why are people who go to college such snobby pricks??

Most plants, regardless of their origin or nature, are the net product of the soil they are grown in.  Think of it along the lines of ?you are what you eat.?

If a soil is contaminated with radioactive elements, or heavy metals, then it is very likely some of those things will be found in the plants growing in that soil.  (hang in there, I do have a point with all of this).

Many farms are under pressure to get the most out of the land that they can and this often means using chemical fertilizers and pesticides.  Some of it is out of choice, and some of it is out of ignorance, some of it is by random chance.  What is applied to the plants and soil often ends up in the plants and plant byproducts.

Even an organic farmer isn't immune to the practices of someone else.  I could take cow manure and spread it on my fields as a more natural way to fertilize my fields ? but if the person or farm that I was getting manure from used a lot of antibiotics in their herd (like dairy farmers are often forced to do to maintain high milk production) then those antibiotics will find their way into the animal's waste and eventually into my field ? where some of it will invariably be taken up by the plants I am growing.

Even if I did everything right I might still be bordering or downwind of an ag operation that incorporated a lot of questionable practices and still end up with my soil being impacted.  Things like the use of aerial spraying (using a plane to spray crops) by a farm that isn't even next door can impact a  pretty wide swath of area around that field sometimes drift miles before completely settling out of the air.

If I was growing organic in that area  then someone might test my crop and say ?why do organic crops have so many antibiotics and pesticides in them? ? and if I was growing genetically modified crops someone could ask the same sort of question.

It is not necessarily the crop or its origins that is the problem.  Sometimes the problem is local and has to do with the techniques,  materials, and land management style(s) used to grow that particular crop.  Sometimes the problem isn't local to that farm but someone nearby.  Sometimes comes from either further away.  MANY antibiotics find their way into the local water supply because waste treatment plants don't remove those things before dumping the treated water into a nearby river or stream.  Anybody downstream using that water (in a personal or agricultural sense)is going to be impacted by the use of antibiotics of the people upstream.

So the question of antibiotics and pesticides in genetically modified crops is not the question that you should be asking because GMCs is not the real issue in that regard and is a misleading question.  The real issue is how those two contaminates are finding their way into a lot of what we eat and drink.
New Topic      
Explore
Post your homework questions and get free online help from our incredible volunteers
  1899 People Browsing
Show Emoticons
:):(;):P:D:|:O:?:nerd:8o:glasses::-):-(:-*O:-D>:-D:o):idea::important::help::error::warning::favorite:
Related Images
  
 1327
  
 201
  
 384
Your Opinion
Which of the following is the best resource to supplement your studies:
Votes: 388

Previous poll results: Where do you get your textbooks?