× Didn't find what you were looking for? Ask a question
Top Posters
Since Sunday
5
a
5
k
5
c
5
B
5
l
5
C
4
s
4
a
4
t
4
i
4
r
4
New Topic  
strawberryyx3 strawberryyx3
wrote...
Donated
Posts: 5
Rep: 2 0
12 years ago
1)   Does natural selection always result in evolution?  In your answer, be sure to define natural selection and evolution.  If you answer yes, explain why this is the case.  If you answer no, explain why and describe a condition under which you can have natural selection with no resultant evolution.

2)   Mutations can be beneficial, neutral, or deleterious.  How would you design an experiment that would allow you to determine the relative proportions of the different kinds of mutations in an organism?  Explain what data you would collect and how you would interpret the data.  What results would you expect to find?

3)   Imagine that you build a phylogeny to determine the relationships between species A, B, and C, and you get the tree shown below.  Explain: 1) why this tree is not helpful in determining those relationships, and 2) one approach that you might take to try to make a phylogeny that is more helpful in determining the relationships between those species.


4)   Darwin considered the process of artificial selection as it operates during domestication when he was developing his theory of evolution by natural selection.  Describe two significant similarities and one major difference between artificial selection and natural selection.
Source  Evolutionary Analysis 4E Freeman
 Attached file 
Thumbnail(s):
You must login or register to gain access to this attachment.
Read 3049 times
3 Replies

Related Topics

Replies
wrote...
12 years ago
1)   Does natural selection always result in evolution?  In your answer, be sure to define natural selection and evolution.  If you answer yes, explain why this is the case.  If you answer no, explain why and describe a condition under which you can have natural selection with no resultant evolution.

Hmm ... maybe not.

If you understand "evolution" to mean "change in the allele frequencies of a population", then yes, natural selection means that some alleles are being selected for propagation while others are reducing in the population. So yes, that always results in evolution.

It is *possible* that two kinds of selection work in opposite directions, resulting in no net evolution. E.g. some trait may be good for survival, but bad for sexual selection (oh, say the ability to smell bad repels both predators and potential mates).

But then we would say that there is no net selection for the trait.
~Live well, laugh often, and love with all of your heart!~
wrote...
12 years ago
No.
In a clonal monoculture, there can't be any evolution since all organisms are identical. Evolution requires inherited variations.
wrote...
12 years ago
No.
In a clonal monoculture, there can't be any evolution since all organisms are identical. Evolution requires inherited variations.

Just to addresssyuhada ramlee's point. While correct, if there is no variation, then not only is there no evolution, but there can be no natural selection either.

So if we ask the question "is it possible for natural selection to be occurring, but evolution not occurring?", then the answer would be no. .... Unless I'm missing something.

Oh!

I did think of a case where natural selection is occurring, but no evolution.

That is the case of 'fixity' with no mutation.

This is where a particular trait (an allele) has propagated to the entire population. Other alleles may also be present in the population (e.g. recessive alleles), but whenever expressed, are selected against. So the population is in an *equilibrium* ... natural selection is occurring, but no net evolution is occurring. In fact, the selection is *preventing* any change to the allele frequencies.

This would be disturbed if any new mutation were to produce a new allele with a slight advantage over the stable allele.

So the answer is no ... natural selection doesn't ALWAYS result in evolution. It could result in stasis.
~Live well, laugh often, and love with all of your heart!~
New Topic      
Explore
Post your homework questions and get free online help from our incredible volunteers
  1234 People Browsing
Related Images
  
 187
  
 985
  
 595
Your Opinion
Who will win the 2024 president election?
Votes: 3
Closes: November 4