Top Posters
Since Sunday
82
a
50
14
10
G
9
I
8
m
8
7
m
7
K
7
6
b
6
New Topic  
suiren suiren
wrote...
Posts: 347
4 months ago
Scott Murphy is a freshman in college and recently decided to pledge a fraternity, Chi Gamma Omega. As a "pledge" of the fraternity, Scott is forced to participate in a number of initiation activities in order to become a brother of Chi Gamma Omega. Specifically, one night Scott was held down on the ground while other brothers poured shots of vodka into his mouth. Severely intoxicated by the initiation ritual, later that evening Scott broke into a female student's dorm room and sexually assaulted her. Scott is claiming that he mistakenly believed he was entering the room of his girlfriend. Is Scott entitled to the defense of involuntary intoxication? Why or why not?
Textbook 

Criminal Law (Justice Series)


Edition: 2nd
Authors:
Read 119 times
2 Replies
Replies
Answer verified by a subject expert
cuddahy99cuddahy99
wrote...
Posts: 340
4 months ago
Sign in or Sign up in seconds to unlock everything for free.
Student answers will vary. Student should ague why the defense of involuntary intoxication is or is not appropriate. It could be argued that the defendant put himself in the situation and it was his decision to join the fraternity in the first place. However, the defendant could argue that they were coerced to ingest the intoxicant and that he did not have mens rea or intent to commit sexual assault.
1

Related Topics

wrote...
4 months ago
You make an excellent tutor!
New Topic      
Explore
Post your homework questions and get free online help from our incredible volunteers.
Learn More
Improve Grades
Help Others
Save Time
Accessible 24/7
  86 People Browsing
 109 Signed Up Today
Related Images
 924
 4807
 142